Content | Navigation |

NDSU Research Provides Clues for Effective Management of Area Lake

Fargo, N.D. – Lakes have lifecycles of their own and results from more than two decades of research by NDSU professor Malcolm Butler and his students are being used to help determine optimum ways to manage and restore a regional lake managed for migratory waterfowl. Lake Christina, located in Douglas County near the town of Ashby in west central Minnesota, has provided decades of living ecological lab experience for students.

Butler, professor of biological sciences at NDSU, is one of 10 co-authors contributing to “A 200-year perspective on alternative stable state theory and lake management from a biomanipulated shallow lake” to be published in the July edition of the Ecological Applications. The article is available online at

Lake Christina is nationally recognized as a critical staging area for migrating waterfowl, especially canvasback ducks. The lake alternates between cloudy and clear, depending on whether there are aquatic plants known as macrophytes or if there is high phytoplankton density.

NDSU students who worked on Lake Christina over the years worked closely with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Mark Hanson, who received his Ph.D. from NDSU in 1990, is a co-author of the journal article, now working for the Minnesota DNR as a research scientist. Kyle Zimmer, who received his Ph.D. from NDSU in 2001, is also listed as a co-author of the article, working on Lake Christina while a professor at the University of St Thomas.

“NDSU has had a long involvement with Lake Christina, going back to 1985,” said Butler. “At that time, the Minnesota DNR planned a dramatic restoration project on this historic waterfowl lake, by attempting a total eradication of fish.” “The 4000-acre shallow lake had been similarly treated in 1965, with additional treatments in subsequent years.”

As the research published in Ecological Applications describes, repeated treatments had the expected result:  water clarity was restored, plant beds recovered, and waterfowl use increased – but not permanently. To understand what has happened after conditions deteriorate, continuous data, like that provided by Butler and his students, is needed.

The lead authors of the research paper from the Science Museum of Minnesota brought unique expertise as paleolimnologists, studying cores of lake sediments to determine Lake Christina’s historical behavior. The lake is designated as a Wildlife Management Lake and is managed for migratory waterfowl.  Managers walk a fine line, balancing short- and long-term needs, and balancing the interests of ducks and duck hunters at Lake Christina with those of recreational anglers. In the fall of 2012, top-down management will include a series of pumps and pipes installed to draw-down the water level, mimicking the natural winter fish kill.

“The study presents compelling evidence that, in the long run, managers need to focus on strategies that target landscapes, not just the food webs in the lakes themselves – bearing in mind that the short term is also important,” said Mark Hanson, a research scientist with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources and NDSU graduate. “The people that live here today are very much in this culture of ducks and migratory water birds, and the incredible history around them. When we get all sectors working on lake ecology together, that’s a very productive basis for the future.”

Students at North Dakota State University, in collaboration with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, contributed significant contemporary data to this project from long term monitoring efforts at Lake Christina. Research funding for the project over the years was provided by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and other agencies.

NDSU is a student focused, land-grant, research university – an economic engine that educates students, conducts primary research, creates new knowledge and advances technology.

The Ecological Society of America is the world’s largest community of professional ecologists. The 10,000 member Society publishes five journals, convenes an annual scientific conference, and broadly shares ecological information through policy and media outreach and education initiatives.

Student Focused. Land Grant. Research University.

Follow NDSU
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • Google Maps

Phone: 701.231.8045
Physical/delivery address:  1735 NDSU Research Park Drive/Fargo, ND 58102
Mailing address:  P.O. Box 6050—Dept. 4000/Fargo, ND 58108-6050
Page manager: RCA