Insecticides can help reduce the secondary spread of PSbMV by reducing populations of virus-transmitting aphids, but insecticides provide only partial control. Insecticides may provide unsatisfactory results, especially when PSbMV-infected seeds are planted. Nonpersistently transmitted viruses such as PSbMV are carried transiently by aphids, and killing infected aphids with insecticides may result in only a modest reduction in transmission events. Systemic insecticides, which are primarily transported in the sap-conducting (phloem) cells of plants, often provide inconsistent control of nonpersistently transmitted viruses such as PSbMV, which are acquired from and transmitted to epidermal cells on the leaf surface, not phloem cells.
Insecticides are most likely to be successful when applied to prevent the establishment of economically damaging aphid populations, especially when seed-borne transmission of PSbMV has occurred in one field and suppression of secondary spread to neighboring fields is desired.
Insecticide applications are based on aphid populations. Scouting for pea aphids should be conducted at least weekly from late vegetative growth through pod development using a visual count or a 15-inch sweep net.
When peas are grown near alfalfa fields, scouting should be intensified after alfalfa cuttings; alfalfa can be a latent (asymptomatic) host of PSbMV, and cutting alfalfa often results in an influx of aphids into neighboring legume crops. The number of pea aphids in the upper 8 inches of plant tips should be counted on 10 plants from four different areas of the field (a total of 40 plants) or from 25 sweeps with an insect sweep net (every 180 degrees) conducted at four different areas of the field (a total of 100 sweeps).
In field peas, an insecticide application would be justified if aphids reach the economic threshold of more than an average of one to two aphids per plant or 10 aphids per sweep. In lentils, insecticide treatment for pea aphid control should be considered: (1) when the economic threshold of an average of 30 to 40 aphids per sweep is observed, (2) when few natural enemies are present, and (3) when aphid numbers do not decline during a two-day period. If the economic threshold is exceeded, a single application of insecticide usually will be sufficient.
Control at the early pod stage protects the pod-forming and elongation stages, which are very sensitive to aphid damage. Insecticides registered for control of pea aphids in pulse crops can be found in the current NDSU Extension publication “E1143 – North Dakota Field Crop Insect Management Guide” at https://www.ndsu.edu/agriculture/extension/publications/north-dakota-field-crop-insect-management-guide.
This publication was authored by Michael Wunsch, Plant Pathologist, NDSU Carrington Research Extension Center; Julie Pasche, Pulse Crops Pathologist, NDSU Department of Plant Pathology; Janet Knodel, Extension Entomologist, NDSU Department of Plant Pathology; Kevin McPhee, Pulse Crops Breeder, NDSU Department of Plant Sciences; Sam Markell, Extension Plant Pathologist, NDSU Department of Plant Pathology; Venkata Chapara, Area Extension Specialist/Crop Protection, NDSU North Central Research Extension Center; and Shana Pederson, Area Extension Specialist/Cropping Systems, NDSU North Central Research Extension Center, 2014.