No Mow May is a popular conservation movement that encourages people to abstain from mowing their lawns throughout May. The purpose is to allow weeds to grow and flower in the lawn to provide nectar and pollen to nourish early-season pollinators such as bees and butterflies. NDSU Extension does not promote this practice because No Mow May lacks scientific support and is even considered controversial.
No Mow May is a British pollinator movement embraced by the town of Appleton, Wisconsin, where residents pledged to forego spring mowing. Seeing an opportunity to research the subject, Lawrence University scientists decided to study this phenomenon. The researchers compared the diversity and abundance of pollinator species between unmowed residential lawns and mowed parkland. They published a study showing unmowed residential lawns attracted more bee species and larger quantities than mowed parkland. The Lawrence University research study was published and received much national press coverage. Consequently, many communities across the country adopted No Mow May.
Then, something unexpected happened. On Nov. 18, 2022, the original research study was retracted due to “several potential inconsistencies in data handling and reporting.” Scientific journals rarely retract articles that have been published unless there is a severe deficiency. In this case, the scientific basis for No Mow May has been undermined.
No Mow May is problematic for many reasons. Foregoing mowing for an entire month is damaging to lawns right before summer. One important rule of thumb for growing healthy lawns is to never trim off more than one-third the height of your turfgrass at one time. For example, if you allow your lawn to grow 4.5 inches tall, the maximum length that should be removed at one time is 1.5 inches, leaving a 3-inch-tall lawn. No Mow May violates this rule because lawns may grow 12 inches or more monthly. Trimming a 15-inch lawn down to 3 inches on June 1 shocks the health of the turfgrass plants. Even worse, this stress is imposed right before summer, and therefore, the lawn is less able to handle heat and drought.
A second concern is that few homeowners have mower equipment that can efficiently mow and collect tall grass. Consequently, deep swaths of “hay” will be left on the lawn when homeowners mow in June. Excessively long clippings may smother the lawn and will likely cause thatch accumulation. The excessive plant residue will need to be raked up, depriving the lawn of nutrients from the clippings.
Allowing the grass to grow too tall may also hurt pollinators. A Massachusetts study examined bee abundance and richness of suburban lawns mowed once a week, once every two weeks and once every three weeks. The lawns mowed every three weeks had the most flowers, but the lawns mowed every two weeks attracted more bees. How could this be? One possibility is that turfgrass grows faster than flowering weeds. Consequently, the tall grass may hide the flowers and make them harder for bees to find.
A final concern is that No Mow May mainly results in blooming dandelions. Yes, many pollinator species visit dandelions for their nectar, and it can be an important early food source in the absence of other pollen-rich plants. However, recent research has shown that dandelion pollen is deficient in several critical amino acids necessary for bees.
If you want to support pollinator conservation in spring, there are better methods than No Mow May. Consider installing a pollinator garden with spring-blooming plants. Spring flowering trees and shrubs can also be an essential source of nutrition until Dutch white clover blooms in June.
Adapted from McGinnis, E. Dakota Gardener: The messy and controversial science behind No Mow May, May 24, 2023.
Retraction Notice. 2022. PeerJ. https://peerj.com/articles/10021/retraction/